On May 14, 2026, the Supreme Court decided Montgomery v. Caribe Transport II. The vote was unanimous: federal law does not shield freight brokers from state-law claims that they negligently selected an unsafe motor carrier. Those claims fall within the safety exception of the Federal Aviation Administration Authorization Act (FAAAA).
For years, many brokers treated preemption as a backstop. That backstop is gone. Carrier selection is now a liability decision, not just a procurement one.
Why shippers should care
The ruling is about brokers, but the question it raises lands on every shipper's desk: who picked the truck, and can they prove they picked it carefully?
Shippers that exercise control over carrier selection have long faced their own negligent-hiring exposure under state law. After Montgomery, plaintiffs' attorneys have a clearer path to everyone in the selection chain, and the quality of your broker's vetting becomes part of your own risk picture.
What "careful" looks like
The Court did not define a standard of care. That will be worked out in state courts. In his concurrence, Justice Kavanaugh pointed to brokers that maintain a reasonable selection policy and ask hard questions. In practice that means, at minimum:
- Active operating authority, checked at booking, not just at onboarding.
- Insurance on file that meets or exceeds the load's requirements.
- Safety record review, including the carrier's FMCSA rating and inspection history.
- Identity verification, so the carrier who shows up is the carrier who was booked.
- A written record of every check, tied to the load.
How we handle it
Compliance is the core of what we do at Fide Freight. Every carrier is vetted before it touches a load, and every check is documented so you can see it.
This article is general information, not legal advice. Talk to your counsel about your company's specific exposure.
